Supergrass: In It For The Money
Monday, April 26th, 2010You’ll wanna see the band playing bish bash bosh tonight
- “Tonight”
Supergrass is one in a long line of over-hyped bands from England that pretty much flopped in the United States. Stone Roses, Oasis, Arctic Monkeys…help me out…there’s so many. “Flopped” might be too strong a word, especially in the case of Oasis, but these bands never live up to their hype: they’re always supposed to be “the next Beatles,” and not only do they not live up to that impossible standard; their eventual impact hardly ever makes them next Rick Astley.
In It For The Money, the band’s second album (so they’d already been vetted and discarded in the States by this point), starts off with a real good groove on the title track and I begin to think the Yanks may have had this one wrong. But they immediately ruin the whole thing by going with the chorus too many times at the end and then screw up, I can only guess intentionally since making it awesome should have required next to no effort, the transition to the next song, “Richard III,” one of the best on the record.
And that’s kind of how it goes through the whole album: unrealized promise. The first three tracks kick it hard, then there’s a couple of mediocre tracks, then another great one, then the worst song on the album (“Going Out”), and so on. There’s enough quality on this that it’s hard for me to grant it three lunchboxes, my lowest rating for a CD I like, but given that it never seems to achieve greatness for more than a couple minutes at a time, the inanity of the non-keepers, and the lack of easy enjoyability (it’s just hard to sink into), three lunchboxes is what it deserves.
Listen, I’m not saying Brits have bad musical taste. They probably do, but that’s not what I’m saying right now. What I am saying is that two places separated by an ocean, no matter how similar their cultures or how easy technology has made media distribution, will develop different tastes. Furthermore, those tastes will diverge as younger generations grow up hearing different songs in their youth, creating different and divergent aesthetic sensibilities. And so STOP FUCKING TELLING ME I’M GOING TO LIKE WHATEVER SHIT ALL THE WANKERS IN ENGLAND THINK IS THEIR NEXT FUCKING GIFT TO AMERICAN RADIO AND THEN WRITING CONDESCENDING ARTICLES ABOUT HOW AMERICANS DON’T LIKE WHAT SOUNDS SO OBVIOUSLY FUCKING FANTASTIC TO YOU!
I’ve been holding that in for over a decade. F**kin’ music critics.
Rating:

Mixers: “You Can See Me,” “Sometimes I Make You Sad”
Non-keepers: “Late In The Day,” “Going Out,” “Hollow Little Reign”
Filed Between: Sunny Day Real Estate (The Rising Tide [Japanese Import]) and Matthew Sweet (100% Fun)









